Mailbox theft can happen anywhere — in big cities, quiet suburbs, and rural neighborhoods. Criminals aren’t just after handwritten letters. Today’s mailboxes often contain items of high value: bank statements, government documents, personal data, checks, and online purchases. For many people, the mailbox has become a target for identity theft. The question is: how do I prevent mailbox theft and protect my personal information?
This complete guide breaks down the best strategies to secure your mailbox, spot suspicious activity, and protect yourself from mail fraud.
Why criminals target residential mailboxes
Mailboxes have become attractive targets because:
-
They are usually accessible
-
They often contain sensitive documents
-
Many homeowners don’t check them regularly
-
Mail theft can lead to identity fraud
Criminals know that one stolen piece of mail can give access to:
-
Banking information
-
Credit card offers
-
Social Security details
-
Tax documents
-
Personal data
Mailbox theft is more than a nuisance — it is a gateway to identity theft.
Install a locking mailbox
One of the most effective ways to prevent mailbox theft is to install a locking mailbox. Unlike a standard mailbox that anyone can open, locking mailboxes:
-
Prevent thieves from reaching inside
-
Are built with reinforced metal
-
Require a key to access mail
Characteristics of a secure locking mailbox:
✅ Heavy-duty steel or aluminum
✅ Anti-pry locking mechanism
✅ Narrow mail slot (discourages hand access)
✅ USPS-approved (if you are in the United States)
Avoid cheap models with simple flip locks. Thieves can pop those open in seconds.
The stronger the mailbox, the less likely a thief is to attempt stealing from it.
Retrieve your mail quickly
Thieves often rely on opportunity. The longer mail stays in your box, the higher the risk of theft.
Tips to protect your mailbox:
-
Get your mail every day, ideally as soon as it arrives
-
Don’t leave your mailbox full overnight
-
If you receive important documents, monitor delivery tracking
If thieves see that your mailbox is regularly emptied, they are less likely to target it.
Use USPS Informed Delivery (or your local postal tracking service)
If you live in the United States, USPS offers Informed Delivery, a free service that sends you daily scans of the mail you will receive.
You know:
-
What should arrive today
-
Whether something is missing
-
If theft occurred
If you’re outside the US, check whether your national postal service offers similar tracking options.
Consider a parcel delivery box
Packages are an increasingly common target. If you receive online orders regularly, thieves may target your house for porch piracy.
A package delivery box helps:
-
Keep parcels safe
-
Prevent visibility from the street
-
Reduce theft risk
Many models lock automatically when the delivery driver closes the lid.
Some advanced versions include:
-
Smart locks
-
Keypad access
-
App notifications
This is one of the best upgrades if you often receive packages when you're not home.
Use a PO Box or commercial mailbox service
If you frequently receive:
-
Checks
-
Legal documents
-
High-value mail
Consider using a PO Box at your local post office.
Advantages:
-
Theft-proof (mail is kept inside a locked building)
-
Accessible anytime depending on location
-
Secure for business or personal mail
Another option is a commercial mailbox service such as UPS Store or a coworking mailbox. They handle packages from all carriers (not only USPS).
Add lighting and a security camera
Thieves prefer dark, hidden areas. Improving visibility around your mailbox can discourage them.
Security upgrades include:
-
Solar-powered motion lights
-
A doorbell camera pointing toward the street
-
A security camera near the mailbox
Bonus: If theft occurs, camera footage helps law enforcement identify the thief.
Stop putting outgoing mail in your mailbox
The outgoing mail flag on curbside mailboxes is a major problem: raising it signals to thieves, “There's mail with personal information here!”
To prevent mailbox theft, never leave outgoing mail in your mailbox.
Instead:
-
Bring outgoing mail directly to the post office
-
Drop it inside an official USPS blue collection box
-
Use secure drop-off points at your workplace
Outgoing mail is the biggest risk, because it often contains:
-
Checks
-
Bills with account numbers
-
Personal information
Keep your mailbox in good physical condition
A damaged mailbox attracts thieves. It signals weakness and easy access.
Inspect your mailbox regularly for:
-
Loose hinges
-
Rusted screws
-
Bent or cracked doors
A well-maintained mailbox sends a message: "This is not an easy target."
Talk to your neighbors
Neighborhood collaboration is a powerful tool to prevent mailbox theft. Thieves often scout the area before striking.
Ideas to protect your community:
-
Create a neighborhood watch group
-
Share suspicious activity in a chat group (Facebook, WhatsApp, Nextdoor)
-
Help collect mail for neighbors who are traveling
Communities that communicate are less likely to be targeted.
What to do if your mail has already been stolen
Act quickly to reduce risk of identity theft.
-
Report mail theft to your postal service
-
File a police report
-
Place fraud alerts on your credit and bank accounts
-
Track missing packages and report to the sender
In the United States, mail theft is a federal crime. Reporting helps protect you and others in your neighborhood.
FAQ – How do I prevent mailbox theft?
How do I prevent mailbox theft?
Install a locking mailbox, collect mail daily, avoid placing outgoing mail in the box, and use tracking services like USPS Informed Delivery.
Are locking mailboxes theft-proof?
They are not 100% theft-proof, but they dramatically reduce the risk. The goal is to make your mailbox harder to access than others.
Can I put outgoing mail in my mailbox?
You should avoid it. Place outgoing mail at the post office or in official collection boxes.
What should I do if my mail gets stolen?
Report it to the postal service, file a police report, and monitor your bank accounts for suspicious activity.
Is mailbox theft a federal crime?
Yes — in the United States, mail theft is a federal offense and can result in fines and prison time.